In Spite of Prolonged Rally, Top Permabears Still Sticking To Their Story -- Here's Why

As a permabear, my natural inclination is to be bearish on US equities. However, even hardcore permabears like myself are forced to acknowledge an uptrend, and clearly an uptrend exists on the S&P. Below is a weekly chart of SPY, an ETF that tracks the S&P 500. Since March of 2009, we've been in a clear uptrend.

However, let's look at some arguments why it may not last:

1. You will hear many arguments about recovery will be W-shaped, U-shaped, V-shaped, etc. Personally, I agree with fellow permabear Eric Janzsen, who noted that we need to look to the Cyrillic alphabet to find a letter whose shape corresponds to the current economic cycle in the US. Janzsen argues for a Cheh-shaped progression. Basically, that while we may have some seemingly strong bull trends, as we did during the Great Depression, the ultimate trend is still bearish.

2. Stefan Karlsson notes that stocks are still overvalued from a fundamental perspective, noting that earnings of broad baskets of stocks are down 30% while prices are down just 20%.

3. Strict adherents to Austrian economics will note that a recovery cannot really happen so long as malinvestments are not liquidated. Bailouts prevent the liquidation of malinvestments and the return of asset prices to appropriate levels; so long as this situation maintains, a recovery seems unlikely. I agree with this notion from a philosophical perspective, although from a financial perspective, it does not seem to be particularly meaningful. We can have a rally in the stock market and a plagued economy; the two are not mutually exclusive.

Personally I focus on trading the US dollar, though my bias is to short the S&P as it approaches strong resistance levels.

Bears Reported to Have Begun Munching on Bulls Who Have Fallen Into Bear Trap

I'm sorry it has to be this way, folks, I really am. But it looks like the bears have set the trap. The bulls have wandered in. And now, there's only one thing left: for the bears to have their lunch, and for the bulls to meet their fate.

Fundamentally we know the story: unemployment and low retail sales in the US economy are all the talk. And while the January effect coupled with inflationary stimulus packages may have helped the market engineer a bit of a rally, the economic woes are still clearly in place, and it looks as though the primary trends are preparing to resume themselves. For instance, at the time of this writing, S&P 500 futures are pointing to a fifth loss in a row.

Technically we see a nice potential trade lining up on SPY, particularly if SPY can break support at 85.43. The market is now trading below the 5, 10, 20, and 50 simple moving averages, all of which are converging -- another indication the bear market rally may be concluding. A break below 85.43 could pave the way for a retest of previous lows at 75.

Check the chart below.

A lower S&P 500 is also generally correlated to a stronger yen. We have seen the yen begin to rally again, as the USDJPY exchange rate has broken below 90. The chart below plots the USJPY (blue and gray candles) against the SPY (red and green candles). In sum, a resumption of the bear trend in the S&P would be a bearish sign for USDJPY, which stock market traders can take advantage of via the FXY ETF.

Disclosure: Short USDJPY.

Discuss this article with me and others on InformedTrades.